Hyperbaric oxygen therapy: a possible choice for patients with resistant thin endometrium during frozen embryo transfer treatments
Read the paperWhat they asked
For an embryo to implant, the lining of the womb (the endometrium) needs to be thick enough and well enough supplied with blood. In IVF, a lining under about 7 millimetres on the day of embryo transfer is often treated as too thin, and some women's linings stay thin despite every standard remedy. Li and colleagues in Changsha, China, asked whether a course of hyperbaric oxygen could thicken a persistently thin lining and whether embryo transfers then went ahead.
Who took part
Women undergoing frozen embryo transfer whose previous cycles had been cancelled because the lining stayed under 7 millimetres despite standard and add-on treatments. From 398 women screened, 55 agreed to hyperbaric oxygen. Using statistical matching on factors such as age and lining history, 41 treated women were paired with 41 similar women who did not have the treatment. This is a matched cohort study, not a randomised trial.
What they did
Treated women attended daily sessions at 2.5 ATA, each lasting about 100 minutes in total (20 minutes pressurising, 60 minutes at pressure, 20 minutes depressurising), breathing 100 per cent oxygen for 70 minutes of that time. Sessions ran through the first half of the cycle, when the lining is building, and stopped on the day progesterone was started. The minimum course was 10 sessions; the average was about 28, with a wide spread. Lining thickness was measured by ultrasound before and after, and the team recorded whether the cycle was cancelled, whether embryos implanted, and pregnancy rates.
What they found
Average lining thickness rose from about 5.8 to 6.6 millimetres, a change of under one millimetre but statistically significant (p = 0.002). The proportion of cycles cancelled fell from 62 per cent to 19 per cent. In the matched comparison, the embryo implantation rate was 33 per cent in the treated group against 11 per cent in controls (p = 0.008). For women transferring blastocysts (day-5 embryos), clinical pregnancy was 54 per cent versus 18 per cent (p = 0.017); for earlier-stage embryos there was no difference. Live birth rates were not the focus and should not be inferred from these figures.
Why it might work
The endometrium regrows every cycle from a thin base layer, and that growth depends on the spiral arteries bringing blood and oxygen up through the tissue. A thin, poorly supplied lining is thought to be a relatively low-oxygen environment. Raising dissolved oxygen may support the growth of new capillaries and the proliferation of the lining cells, and may improve receptivity, the short window in which the lining can accept an embryo. The study did not measure blood flow directly, so this remains the proposed rather than the demonstrated mechanism.
Limits
Women chose whether to have treatment, so those who did may have differed in motivation or other unmeasured ways; matching reduces but does not remove that bias. Forty-one pairs is a small group and the pregnancy sub-analyses are smaller still. The number of sessions varied enormously. Doppler blood-flow measurements were not taken, and the authors note the timing of lining preparation was not uniform. The gain in thickness was small in absolute terms. No funding source was clearly stated in the version we read. A randomised trial is needed before any firm conclusion, and nothing here promises a pregnancy to any individual.







